Blog Entry

We were misled about Renardo Sidney

Posted on: August 26, 2011 9:58 am
By Matt Norlander

We said it wasn't a good sign more than a month ago. Renardo Sidney did not take the trip with Mississippi State when the Bulldogs went overseas at the beginning of August. It was originally believed that he chose under his own volition -- perhaps even rebelliously -- to go to Houston to work out with John Lucas and improve his game, as well as his attitude.

Let's be clear and shed a light for fans, who probably already know this, but just in case. Overseas trips only happen a few years, per rule, for college programs. When they do get them, they're expensive, require a lot of planning and are pretty important to the coaches. For those who've ever traveled to Europe or Asia or Africa or Australia: think about the prep you did, then multiply that by about 20. Coaches want the whole team together if the whole team is permitted to go. There is some credence to the cliche that these trips are good for group bonding. Many a coach will tell you some of these excursions really, truly can be a positive impact for the season ahead.

For a player to get left behind, it's usually a rule, a serious injury/illness or a punishment for some harsh behavior. We now know Sidney didn't go to Europe because of Mississippi State coach Rick Stansbury -- not because Sidney chose to stay behind. Stansbury said this Thursday to Brandon Marcello of the Clarion-Ledger, as well as other members of the local media down in Starkville, Miss.:

“Let’s make sure to get this clear: it was not his decision to go to Houston,” Stansbury said. “Everybody understand that. I made that decision, nobody else made that decision. I made the decision, OK? That’s where that is and, again, would I have liked for him to have been on the trip? I would have and it would have been good, but there are some things he had to handle that he hadn’t handled. Since then, he has. ... He fulfilled some obligations he had to have for the team. And he did that. So, we’ll see if he keeps progressing. We all want to hope and believe he can.”

There are still hurdles for Sidney to clear and much peace of mind to accomplish on Stansbury's behalf. Stansbury, in many ways, has put his job on the line to keep Sidney in a Mississippi State uniform. He stuck his neck out last season; Sidney played in 19 games and averaged 14 points, 7.6 rebounds per game. The Bulldogs went 17-14.

I'm not certain Sidney's going to change. He's back on Twitter, with a new handle that doesn't really compute -- LawandOrder1. Alrighty. Listen, I'd love for Sidney to play well, stay on the right path and not make Stansbury look like a fool. But it's evident there are still problems existing between coach and player, and perhaps player and team.

Because Sidney didn't make the trip, this has now reached the point where, even if Stansbury and Sidney say there isn't a problem, speculation will continue well into the season. Until Sidney has an extended period of good play and better behavior, he and his coach have put themselves into a situation where questions will continue to be asked about whether he was ever remotely worth having on the team.

Photo: AP

Since: Jan 21, 2010
Posted on: August 27, 2011 8:33 am

We were misled about Renardo Sidney

Rick Stansbury appears to be a very poor judge of character.

Since: Dec 5, 2006
Posted on: August 27, 2011 2:23 am

We were misled about Renardo Sidney

You don't say who misled you. The context makes it seem like it was coach Stansbury. He clearly did not set the record straight at the time. Coach has multiple problems just now and that is troubling for MSU fans. Losing D.J. Gardner to a Twitter attack is sad unusual. I cannot remember a similar incident from a current player against his coach.

From the account here the trip was useful in gaining the ten practices and the game experience in Italy. Sidney should have been able to go and apparently failed to complete his requirements from what can only be termed a team probation. Can this team regroup and stabilize? I hope so. Good programs are hard to establish and can be undone by a few mistakes. Most believe Sidney was a mistake. Now it appears that Gardner was also a mistake. Character, character, character. Without it no team can prosper.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or